INTEREST CHARGE – DOMESTIC
INTERNATIONAL SALES CORPORATION
What is an Interest
Charge – Domestic International Sales Corporation?
Better known as IC-DISC, was originally created as a Domestic
International Sales Corporation in 1971 to stimulate U.S. exports, IC-DISC is a
variation of the original creation. It allows U.S. owners of a qualified
business tax savings on a calculated percent of qualified export sales.
What are the tax
savings? Instead of the exporting company paying up to
a 35 percent federal corporate tax on 100 percent of export NET income, a tax deductible
commission is paid to the IC-DISC Corporation.
When the commission received by the IC-DISC Corporation is distributed
to its shareholders, they pay an individual tax rate based on the qualified dividend
tax rate. Depending on the shareholder’s
ordinary income tax rate that could be between ZERO to 20 percent in 2013. For example if the Corporation is in the 35
percent Federal tax rate and a shareholder has a 15 percent dividend tax rate, the
shareholder realizes a 20 percent federal tax savings. This is a permanent tax savings and not
reversed in later years.
Depending
on how the IC-DISC is set up, IC-DISC income may or may not be considered
income that is subject to the additional 3.8% Medicare Tax. There is alot of ambiguity and no tax court
cases to rely on. In general the 3.8%
Medicare Tax is a tax on investment or passive income. If the IC-Disc is set up as a Commission DISC
[see the discussion on how a Commission DISC works on page 2], the dividends
will be considered coming from a passive activity, then the Medicare Tax
applies. However if the IC-DISC is set
up as a Buy/Sell DISC where the export activities occur in the DISC corporation
[see the discussion on how a Buy/Sell DISC works on page 2], then the income is
not from a passive activity and Medicare Tax on Investment Income does not
apply. However this has not been tested in court and it is my opinion the IRS
will take the position that the Medicare Tax still applies because the word
dividend is used in the code. But I
believe the IRS would be incorrect and tax should not apply because the Buy/Sell
DISC is not a passive activity and the distributions out of the DISC are not
true dividends, just taxed as a dividend.
As in many other cases the IRS could lose in court. But like I said before this has not been
tested in court and taking this position is aggressive and even though, in my
opinion, has merit the Taxpayer could lose in court
Unfortunately
not all states recognize the IC-DISC, California is one of them. Some tax consultants take the position that
if the IC-DISC is organized in a state outside of California, like Nevada,
California tax can be avoided. However I
believe this is incorrect due to California Nexus rules. Because the DISC and the California export
company are related and the economic activity that creates income in the DISC
occurs in California, a combined return will be required and tax paid.
Additional tax
savings
There are a number of related planning
opportunities associated with this technique. An IC-DISC can be used as a
succession planning tool to accumulate cash on a tax-advantaged basis to
facilitate a buyout of the Exporter itself. Exporters have also used these
entities to provide equity incentives to key management personnel without the
drawbacks of granting an equity interest in the Exporter itself. Care must be
taken in structuring these types of arrangements if the shareholders of the
IC-DISC are not the same as the shareholders of the Exporter, although such
arrangement is permitted.
Because the IC-DISC does not pay
income tax, and its shareholders are only taxed when distributions are made,
other planning opportunities exist if these shareholder distributions are
deferred. For instance, the IC-DISC can loan the commission payments back to
the Exporter.
Interest paid on this indebtedness
generates another deduction for the Exporter, and the interest income is
treated as a dividend to the shareholders. The same tax savings described above
are effectively realized on the financing transaction. If distributions of
commission income are deferred, there is an interest change (which is
deductible for corporation shareholders). This interest change is based on the
deferred tax liability of the shareholder and the base period Treasury bill
rate.
Who should consider
forming an IC-DISC? An IC-DISC may be established at any time
during the year by any non-publicly traded corporation that earns significant income from
exporting goods, including software, or from engineering or architectural
services on foreign construction projects.
The corporation must be organized under the laws of a state or the
District of Columbia and meet the following tests:
(1)
At
least 95% of its gross receipts in the DISC during the tax year are qualified
export receipts. The 95% rule does not
apply to all gross receipts of the export company, just the gross receipts in
the DISC.
(2)
At
the end of the tax year, the adjusted basis of its qualified export assets is
at least 95% of the sum of the adjusted basis of all of its assets in the DISC.
(3)
The
DISC has only one class of stock, and its outstanding stock has a par or stated
value of at least $2,500 on each day of the tax year (or, for a new
corporation, on the last day.
(4)
The
DISC maintains separate books and records.
(5)
The
DISC is not a member of any controlled group of which a foreign sales
corporation (FSC) is a member.
(6)
Its
tax year of the DISC must conform to the tax year of the principal shareholder(s)
who has the highest percentage of voting power.
How does an IC-DISC
work?
Commission DISC
(1) The exporting company forms an IC-DISC
corporation, which generally mirrors the ownership structure of the exporting
company.
(2) The IC-DISC charges the exporting
company a commission on NET income related to export sales using one of the two
following methods, whichever is greater:
·
The ‘Four-Percent’ Gross Receipt Method
·
50% of NET income
(3) The exporting company fully deducts the
commission expense.
(4) The IC-DISC distributes profits to its
shareholders via dividends
(5)
U.S. income
tax is imposed on the IC-DISC shareholder’s dividends on the shareholder’s
personal tax return.
(6)
No
employees are required within the Commission DISC and the entity has no effect
on exporting operations.
Buy/Sell DISC
(1)
The
exporting company forms an IC-DISC corporation, which generally mirrors the
ownership structure of the exporting company.
(2)
The
DISC takes title to the goods it exports and operates as an export subsidiary
with employee(s) who handles the export functions such as purchasing, invoicing.
(3)
A
commission rate, using the arm's length transfer pricing rules of the IRS
regulations (IRC Section 482), is established to pay the related supplier for
the goods it takes title of.
(4)
100%
of the profits related to export sales are captured at the lower tax rate
rather than only the commission element as in (2) above.
(5)
The
IC-DISC distributes profits to its shareholders via dividends
(6)
U.S. income
tax is imposed on the IC-DISC shareholder’s dividends on the shareholder’s
personal tax return.
Other
Forms
There are other forms to be considered.
They are as follows:
(a) Safe Harbor Buy/Sell IC-DISC. The
IC-DISC purchases and sells export property. The parent company reimburses the
IC-DISC-paid export promotion expenses plus 10 percent. Does not require an IRC
Section 482 transfer pricing study.
(b)
Export
Invoice Factoring. The IC-DISC purchases invoices (connected to the commissions
paid) from the parent company on a non-recourse, discounted basis (e.g., at a
3% or 4% discount rate). Requires an IRC Section 482 transfer pricing study.
(c)
IC-DISC
with Foreign International Sales Corporation (FISC). The IC-DISC owns 100 percent of a FISC that
buys and on-sells inventory at a mark-up to foreign customers. The FISC must be
located in a jurisdiction outside the 50 states and Puerto Rico. The parent
company pays a commission to the IC-DISC for the FISC sales and requires an IRC
Section 482 transfer pricing study.
Cautions
The IC-DISC
is considered a Tier 1 audit issue by the IRS and requires additional due
diligence to ensure compliance and substantiation of company practices. Tier I audit issues are of “high strategic
importance” to the IRS and have a significant impact on one or more industries.
Tier I issues may involve a large number of taxpayers, a significant dollar
amount, a substantial compliance risk or high visibility. Issues will be placed
in this category if the IRS has an established legal position or directive out
on the issue. In other words, if you form
an IC-DISC, it could be a “red flag” for audit.
Normally if a taxpayer is honest and follows the rules, with
transparency, an audit should not deter them from taking appropriate tax positions. The IC-DISC rules are complex and time
consuming, if the IC-DISC is set up improperly, calculated incorrectly or lacks
substantiation, your business could face additional taxes, penalties, and
interest. Thus it is imperative that you
seek proper tax advice from a CPA or tax attorney.
Applicable tax codes
(1)
Internal
Revenue Code § 995(f)
(2)
Treasury
Regulation § 1.995(f)-1(d).
(3)
IRS
Instructions for Form 1120-IC-DISC
(4)
IC-DISC
Audit Guide [LB&I-04-0212-003]
Summary
The Interest
Charge – Domestic International Sales Corporation, also known as IC-DISC,
allows qualified US exports a tax deductible commission from business net
income equal to 50 percent of NET export income. That commission is then distributed to the
shareholder of the IC-DISC Corporation as a dividend and the shareholder pays
an individual tax rate based on the qualified dividend tax rate when the
dividend is distributed